Deprecated: preg_replace(): The /e modifier is deprecated, use preg_replace_callback instead in /membri/massimotessitori/sovietwarplanes/board/Sources/Load.php(225) : runtime-created function on line 3

Deprecated: preg_replace(): The /e modifier is deprecated, use preg_replace_callback instead in /membri/massimotessitori/sovietwarplanes/board/Sources/Load.php(225) : runtime-created function on line 3
Print Page - early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks

Sovietwarplanes

Great Patriotic War Aviation => Yaks => Topic started by: Massimo Tessitori on June 01, 2011, 11:46:18 AM



Title: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Massimo Tessitori on June 01, 2011, 11:46:18 AM
Hi all,
looking at photos of Yaks, I am strongly suspecting that something should be rewritten.
Probably the first application of AMT-11 and 12 on many Yakovlev planes, in 1943, was made according to a different scheme that we can describe as 'serpentine'.
(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/colors/1943-45-fighters/yak9-niivvs.jpg)
Image from SAFFC by EP It has often interpreted as a tricky black-green or tractor green-dark green scheme, but the photo here allows the comparison with the colors of the MiG-3, Il-2 and Pe-2, and it's clear that it can't absolutely be the same. So, it's likely that this was a first application of AMT-11/12.
Note the high contour of the AMT-7 light blue demarcation line on the fuselage sides, that encourages the interpretation as a blue-gray plane, and the early style marks.
Note the wing of a La-5, believed to be white or light grey overall.

Massimo



Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Massimo Tessitori on June 01, 2011, 11:49:51 AM
(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/colors/1943-45-fighters/yak7b8b.jpg)
An image of a Yak-7B with the very same livery, presumably in late 1942 or early 1943.


(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/colors/1943-45-fighters/yak7b-windtunnel.jpg)
A Yak-7b in the wind tunnel at TsAGI. The same livery is evident.

(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/colors/1943-45-fighters/yak7pd-pvo.jpg)
Yak-7PD of the Moscow PVO. Again the same livery... Note the funny loop on the wing.

Massimo


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Massimo Tessitori on June 01, 2011, 11:52:32 AM
(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/colors/1943-45-fighters/yak7di.jpg)
Yak-7DI, practically the prototype of Yak-9, shows a comparable livery, possibly made with grey AMT-11 and black (or, alternatively, with the fantomatic tractor green and black).

(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/colors/1943-45-fighters/yak9-0118niivvs1.jpg)

(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/colors/1943-45-fighters/yak90118niivvs2.jpg)

Yak-9 c/n 0118 at NII VVS in February or March 1943. Again, it wears the serpentine livery supposedly made of AMT-11 and 12, still with old style red stars.

Massimo


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Massimo Tessitori on June 01, 2011, 11:56:23 AM
(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/colors/1943-45-fighters/yak1moskit1.jpg)

(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/colors/1943-45-fighters/yak1moskit2.jpg)

(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/colors/1943-45-fighters/yak1moskit3.jpg)

(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/colors/1943-45-fighters/yak1moskit4.jpg)

Four images of the first prototype of Yak-1M Moskit in the spring of 1943, with the supposed grey/grey serpentine camouflage. The second prototype had already the better known NKAP 1943 camouflage.

And that is all for now.
Regards
Massimo


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: mholly on June 01, 2011, 02:26:53 PM
Massimo.
Order for new camo-BOTH paints and patterns-was issued in July 1943 i.e. well after the dates you ascribe to your pictures.
More importantly, AMT-11/12 were NOT ready for mass production and distribution in July'43 and temporary formula to mix approximate shades from AMT-6 and AMT-7 was allowed. "True" camos in AMT-11/12 cannot be dated sooner than late summer 1943.
Those PATTERNS are something else however and definitely worth further consideration.
Cheers,
Mario


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Massimo Tessitori on June 01, 2011, 05:43:05 PM
Hi Mario,
I know that the order is of July 1943 and includes a new template, but take in account that Yakovlev introduced the black/green camouflage on many of his Yaks already in 1940, at least six months before it was officialized.
Quote
The NKAP order and the Air Force determined the procedure for the introduction of the new camouflage patterns in practice. Delivery of all necessary enamels should be provided by 25 July [1943]. For the release of the new camouflage fighters were scheduled from 15 July, the remaining aircraft - from 1 August, but before that date, from July 15, prescribed in the existing two-colour production machines to replace the black on dark gray. Prior to receiving the standard gray-blue and dark gray colours they were allowed to use a mixture of nitroemaley of AMT-7 (blue) and AMT-6 (black) or oil A-26m and A-28m, made by special instructions and standards of the VIAM. Such a blending of colours had never before been allowed, such was the special urgency of introducing a new camouflage. Documentary evidence of the use of mixtures of dyes were found as well as the ?special? guidelines and standards. However, to exclude their use in the initial stage of implementation of the new camouflage cannot be made. In this case, the colours of enamel might have significantly differed from the AMT-11 and AMT-12 (A-32m).
So, in July 1943 they received instructions to obtain grey paints by mixing black and light blue. They could have donr the same in late 1942. But why?

Quote
Let's see, how are we looking at wooden structure and skinned aircraft. Plywood was attached to the frame and was covered with two layers of nitrokleya. Then a thin layer of putty was applied, then again the nitrokleya layer, and finally the cloth was attached, which was covered with two layers of shpatpevki, primers layer dope AN Al (in wartime, this layer cannot be), and two layers of AMT dope.
In late 1942 - early 1943 NKHP factory in Chelyabinsk and Novosibirsk in nitroshpatlevke AL-22 short lead kroons, which is included in its composition, was replaced in iron minium. This shpatpevka was applied to aviation all winter and spring. During the summer heat the layer shpatpevki had internal stresses, causing the paint layer to crack. Through the cracks penetrated moisture, which sharply reduced the strength of the attaching skin and led to its isolation. Cracking happened for about a thousand aircraft painted with the use of this shpatpevki. ?Greshipi? this fighter Yak-7 plants,  number 153, Yak-1 plant number 292 and La-5 plants number 21 and number 99. Machines lost their fighting efficiency. Abandoned in front of the factory team for two or three weeks back in operation defective aircraft, and literally within two or three days after the completion of writes A.S. Yakovlev, began the famous battle on the Orel-Kursk direction.
Thus, the defect was the cause of poor quality coating, a formula which forcibly took the lead crowns. As can be seen, to solve the deficit problem by filling it was not possible. But the lead crowns belonged to the green enamel A-24m and AMT-4. If you cannot abandon it in the fillings, it may be to reduce the flow of paint on the [crown]?  Reserve formulae include the possibility of replacing the krona and milori with one pigment - green oxide of chromium, and chromium oxide was scarce: in 1943 according to the NKAP there was only 53.8% of the required amount.  Cannot proved and the replacement of lead krone to another - zinc: in March 1943 in ?with complete absence of zinc krone? halted production of soil ALG-1 and ALG-5. The answer remained one - drastically reduce the production of green enamel. ?Plans ...? 1943, just respond to such a solution: the most massive class of aircraft - fighters - green is missing completely, as for other machines the need for green colours was to be reduced by more than 1.6 times.
So, they have changed the wood primer with a worst one because lead was scarce, and lead was a component of AMT-4, aside chromium oxide that was scarce too. So, there is a reason for an anticipation of what was later officialized.
Again, the only other alternative interpretation that I see is the one of tractor green, because the lighter color clearly isn't the same AMT-4 of the other planes of the first photo.
Couldn't anyone ask the opinion of the Russian colleagues on the interpretation of these photos?
Regards
Massimo


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: KL on June 01, 2011, 07:59:00 PM
Again, the only other alternative interpretation that I see is the one of tractor green...
Regards
Massimo

Massimo, there was no Tractor Green!  (http://karopka.ru/bitrix/images/forum/smile/ora.gif)


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Massimo Tessitori on June 01, 2011, 09:42:24 PM
Quote
Massimo, there was no Tractor Green!

Not tractor green? What a pity! Maybe sand/brown? No?
Then, what other if not grey/grey?
Regards
Massimo


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: dragonlanceHR on June 01, 2011, 10:09:25 PM
Long live the tractors!

Sometimes the subject of VVS colors research in English feels like one step forward, two steps back...


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: KL on June 01, 2011, 11:44:57 PM
Quote
looking at photos of Yaks, I am strongly suspecting that something should be rewritten.
.... a different scheme that we can describe as 'serpentine'

Massimo, the history has been rewritten - the scheme is already known as "raised ramp" & "loops"

This profile looks plausable:

(http://www.airwar.ru/image/idop/fww2/yak7di/yak7di-c1.jpg)

(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/colors/1943-45-fighters/yak7di.jpg)


This one is suspicious:

(http://www.airwar.ru/image/idop/fww2/yak9/yak9-c3.jpg)

(http://www.airwar.ru/image/idop/fww2/yak9/yak9-1.jpg)


more food for thoughts:  Tiger stripes!  Yak-7-37 prototype

(http://www.airwar.ru/image/idop/fww2/yak7-37/yak7-37-3.jpg)

Cheers,
KL


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Massimo Tessitori on June 01, 2011, 11:56:18 PM
Hi Konstantin,
the grey-grey profile looks plausible to me, the comparison of the NII VVS museum planes show clearly that the Yak-9 isn't with the same colors than the MiG. Il-2 and Pe-2, that are known to be green (the MiG) or green/black (Il-2 and Pe-2).
If there is not any other explanation, I would say that grey/grey camo on Yaks and I-230 existed before the summer of 1943.
Regards
Massimo


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: John Thompson on June 02, 2011, 12:37:23 AM

Massimo, there was no Tractor Green!  (http://karopka.ru/bitrix/images/forum/smile/ora.gif)


Nothing runs (and in this case, runs, and runs, and keeps on running) like a Deere!  :D

(Explanation for non-North Americans: "Nothing runs like a Deere" is the popular advertising slogan for John Deere Tractors. Ironically, "John Deere Green", the colour in which these widely-used tractors are painted, is almost an exact match for the acid green colour used for AMT-4 in many well-known profiles... ;) )

(http://s3.postimage.org/2v8dv08lg/John_Deere_tractors.jpg) (http://postimage.org/image/2v8dv08lg/)

Farmer John


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: learstang on June 02, 2011, 01:11:45 AM
No tractor green!?  But John, Konstantin, when am I ever going to be able to use my two tins of "WW2 Soviet VVS TRACTOR GREEN" (that's what it says helpfully on the tin) that I bought from WEM a few years ago?  On the subject of WEM "Soviet" paints, I finally found a use for their "AII Brown".  I used it to paint the parts for the oil system on my Hobby Boss IL-2.  According to references (including our very own Mr. Tessitori), the colour for the oil system was glossy brown.  I could have used my WEM "Tractor Green" for the coolant system, which one Russian author described as being a "poisonous green", but I don't think it was quite this poisonous-looking so I went with another glossy green.  Besides, I figure those WEM tins with their fictitious VVS colours may be collectors' items someday.  There's positive thinking for you!

Regards,

Jason


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: KL on June 02, 2011, 01:46:35 AM
I still can't figure out what are the correct colours of "Tractor Green" and "Factory Green"

(http://i292.photobucket.com/albums/mm13/klesnikov/Posted%20in%20forums/TractorandFactgreencompared.jpg)

can anybody help???


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: learstang on June 02, 2011, 02:42:20 AM
Konstantin, it's like science-fiction; since they never existed you can make them anything you want to!  Maybe we could have a contest to come up with our own variants of these well-known "VVS colours".  The problem is, if we did that, those colours would start showing up in profiles and kit and decal instructions ("tractor green as seen on the Sovietwarplanes site").  After all, someone had to be the first one to make up the brown/green camouflage scheme.

Regards,

Jason


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Massimo Tessitori on June 02, 2011, 06:39:18 AM
Hi all,
no doubt, the reports on tractor green have to be somehow wrong: even if a factory finds only such acidic green to put on their planes, they would mix it with black and other colors before spraying, because, as it looks, none can see it as a camouflage color.
Neverthless, there is still something very unclear in VVS painting: why do the green appear so light in so many photos of Yaks, and not of Lavochkins and Mig and Pe-2s? Is it only a question of film sensibility? But why did they use different films for Yaks? So, if the tractor green explanation is wrong, there has to be another one.
Maybe they utilized thin layers of green, that let transpare the yellow background to give the idea of a lighter green? 
And so, can factory green be considered as a bad attempt to represent another shade as AII green used on wood (that was darker than the authors thought), 3B or other existing paints?

By the way, John, nice tractor indeed. But it still lacks of black bands. :D
Regards
Massimo


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: learstang on June 02, 2011, 07:27:53 AM
Massimo, speaking of Lavochkin's, what about Galchenko's LaGG-3, with the three topsides colours, two of which appear to be two different greens?  Could this be a case of what you're talking about?  No doubt I think we have a pretty good idea of what paints were painted on the vast majority of 'planes for a given time period, but there are aircraft with schemes that don't fit into any neat NKAP scheme either in terms of their colours or their patterns.  I'm thinking of the single-seater IL-2 shot down in Finland (alongside a Shturmovik with the early overall green scheme), which appears on your page of 1941-1943 schemes (the same page with Galchenko's aeroplane).  It also appears to have three colours, with perhaps two green colours, and the pattern itself is extremely unusual.  There are still questions.  Although these aeroplanes were exceptions, it's this exceptional nature that makes them desirable from a modelling standpoint.  Who wants a veritable squadron of model Lavochkins or Shturmoviks, all painted in the same schemes?

Regards,

Jason


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: mholly on June 02, 2011, 09:11:31 AM
Massimo,
from 2nd Hornat's article
..."8. coloration must be executed only in the standard paints supplied to the aviation units of the following nomenclature: for the wooden and fabric airframe skins green paint AMT-4, light brown AMT-1, dark gray AMT-12, gray-blue AMT-11 and blue AMT-17"...
Why do we need to talk about "tractor green" again?
Even though paints for agricultural equipment were enamels for metals aviation enamels are different, specifically formulated for light alloys! Non-aviation paint just cannot be used on airplanes. If you're still in doubt as far as VVS is concerned there is an overwhelming proof for this in other airforces painting standards. For example Luftwaffe went through years-long process to develop such paints. Japan had to buy paint technology for light metals from Germany.
There is another point you seem to be missing-mentality in the Soviet society at that time. Initiative was not welcome, it was even dangerous. I just cannot imagine some workers mixing "tractor" paint with black to achieve desired shade. They would rather leave the aircraft in primer (silver many time as we all have seen) once prescribed aviation paints were in shortage (and again we know it did happen).
I hate saying it once again but judging from b&w pictures you're making misleading conclusions. And it cann't be otherwise unless you know exactly what type of film was used, what filter if any, exposure time, lighting condition, exact date, maybe some other data. You would have to have either original negative or 1st generation print as well. Only then your chances to determine some color information would be better. Orlov is very specific about this and so are other color researchers.
Cheers,
Mario


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: KL on June 02, 2011, 06:19:47 PM
Neverthless, there is still something very unclear in VVS painting: why do the green appear so light in so many photos of Yaks, and not of Lavochkins and Mig and Pe-2s? Is it only a question of film sensibility? But why did they use different films for Yaks? So, if the tractor green explanation is wrong, there has to be another one.


Two reasons why green AMT-4 looks dark gray on some b/w photos and light gray on others:

1.   Photos were taken with different types of film (different spectral sensitivity) and with different optical filters
2.   AMT-4 had some special spectral properties ? it was non-decodable (nedeshifruemya)


LaGGs camouflaged in black-green scheme also show wide range of grays for AMT-4 painted areas:
 
(http://www.lietadla.com/lietadla/ruske/lagg-3/lagg-3-10.jpg)

(http://ww2warbirds.net/ww2pics/ww2lagglagg3-1.jpg)

Two photos above were taken with different types of film - red star is dark on the upper photo and almost white on the lower photo.

Better forget tractors, Green-Dark Green scheme or South Front Scheme and stick to Vahlamov?s & Orlov?s works.  Photo analysis could be useful to find camouflage patterns, or personal markings; it definitely can?t be used to define colours.

Cheers,
KL

PS:  check some of my earliest posts for explanation what "nondecodable" means


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Massimo Tessitori on June 02, 2011, 07:35:44 PM
Hi all,
I've continued to examinate those photos, and I've discovered an interesting thing: the photo of the Yak-9 at NII VVS museum is exactly the one utilized for tests, so it's clearly grey and grey.
It appears identical in scheme and colors to Yak-7b built months before, to the Yak-7PD that is photographed aside I-230 with the same colors (always thought to be grey and grey, none draws it as green and black) and to the first prototype of Yak-1m (the second prototype, taken presumably with the same film, shows apparently the same colors but with the NKAP 1943 scheme). Same scheme, same apparent colors. That is enough for me.
Quote
There is another point you seem to be missing-mentality in the Soviet society at that time. Initiative was not welcome, it was even dangerous. I just cannot imagine some workers mixing "tractor" paint with black to achieve desired shade. They would rather leave the aircraft in primer (silver many time as we all have seen) once prescribed aviation paints were in shortage (and again we know it did happen).
The Yak fighter were often camouflaged with green and black since the mid of 1940, and the NKAP instructions of 1941 officialized for all builders what Yakovlev was already doing. It seems that it was the same thing in 1943  with the grey-grey scheme.
Besides, there were many compliants about the black-black scheme in 1942, and a general proposed its own one; if Russians were so terrorized to criticize painting schemes, they shouldn't have done this, but wait that the order started from Stalin himself to do anything.
By the way, have you some example of planes sent in combat left in primer?
Regards
Massimo


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Apex1701 on June 02, 2011, 11:05:53 PM
Hi guys,

this photo was shown by Vakhlamov and Orlov in one of their 1998-1999 articles.
My russian is poor and I can be wrong but I think they said it's a black and green camo.
(http://i38.photobucket.com/albums/e136/Apex1701/yak-1.jpg)

Jean


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: mholly on June 03, 2011, 03:54:31 AM
Hi guys,

this photo was shown by Vakhlamov and Orlov in one of their 1998-1999 articles.
My russian is poor and I can be wrong but I think they said it's a black and green camo.
(http://i38.photobucket.com/albums/e136/Apex1701/yak-1.jpg)

Jean
Caption says:
"Yak-1M (Yak-3 test example) manufactured by Moscow plant nr.115 painted in green-black camouflage being tested at NII VVS on February 15, 1943.
Compare this photograph with those taken in PARM nr.1087 where the airplanes were painted according to this scheme but already in 2 shades of gray."
Cheers,
Mario


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Massimo Tessitori on June 03, 2011, 07:40:35 AM
Hi Jean and Mario,
with all the respect for the authors, this is a case where a description of colors is given on the base of the visual impression of the photo. I respectfully disagree.  Note how high is the blue on the sides: for me, this is a scheme apt to distort the shape of the plane when in flight.
However, it's surprisingly interesting where it says that planes made in the same factory with the same scheme were already painted grey-grey in february 1943, months before of the release of the NKAP template.
Regards
Massimo


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: KL on June 03, 2011, 08:09:58 AM
However, it's surprisingly interesting where it says that planes made in the same factory with the same scheme were already painted grey-grey in february 1943, months before of the release of the NKAP template.

It says that Yaks overhauled by a maintance unit in summer 1945 had been painted in similar pattern but in two gray scheme.

HTH  :)
KL


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Apex1701 on June 03, 2011, 12:20:50 PM
It says that Yaks overhauled by a maintance unit in summer 1945 had been painted in similar pattern but in two gray scheme.

Summer 1945 ?
I am not good in russian but I am better with numbers and I can't see anything ressembling 1945 nor than лето ?
 :o

Could you explain. Thanks.

Jean


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: KL on June 03, 2011, 06:18:30 PM
Summer 1945 ?
I am not good in russian but I am better with numbers and I can't see anything ressembling 1945 nor than лето ?
 :o
Could you explain. Thanks.

"Compare this photograph with those taken in PARM nr.1087 where the airplanes were painted according to this scheme but already in 2 shades of gray."  (Thanks Mario!)

sentence above reffers to photos taken in summer 1945.  Check the last photo on Pg 39 for "лето 1945":

(http://i292.photobucket.com/albums/mm13/klesnikov/Posted%20in%20forums/ParmPg38.jpg)

(http://i292.photobucket.com/albums/mm13/klesnikov/Posted%20in%20forums/ParmPg39.jpg)



Cheers,
KL


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Massimo Tessitori on June 04, 2011, 07:18:10 AM
Hi all,

Hi all,
(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/colors/1943-45-fighters/yak9-serpentine-mus.jpg)
This is the only early Yak-9 preserved in Yakovlev collection, and has a grey-grey camouflage similar to the known serpentine. It's believed to have been the plane of I.I.Kleshchev of 434 IAP (thanks to Aleksandr Ruckovski).

Yes, I know, the plane could have been repainted, but take in account that who repainted it saw the original colors. Besides, for what I know, the exhibits of the Yakovlev collection are all painted in credible way.

About the planes in PARM: unfortunately the scans are not visible. By the way, which is the number of M-Hobby where they appear?
The fact that the planes are in PARM and in 1945 doesn't mean that they were all repainted with new colors on an old scheme with old colors. If they want to repaint a new plane to fit a new standard, it's likely that they follow the lines of the 1943 template.  I haven't seen cases of planes that are suspected to have been repainted grey/grey on the old lines of the 1941 template.

At present time, I would say that all evidences are that the serpentine planes were grey. There is only a pair of photos of Yak-9 0104 that looks very dark on 'yakovlev piston-engined fighters', pag.63, but the AMT-7 appears dark too, and the stars appear very light, so I would say that it's a problem of filter on the objective or of a particular film.
Other grey-looking photos are taken in many different occasions, both in factory and operative, so they can't be suspected to have all been altered with the same photographic filter or unusual film.

Regards
Massimo


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: KL on June 04, 2011, 07:53:30 AM
Yes, I know, the plane could have been repainted, but take in account that who repainted it saw the original colors. Besides, for what I know, the exhibits of the Yakovlev collection are all painted in credible way.

Hi Massimo,
Thanks for the nice photo.  It's nice but almost useless for this case.  All planes preserved in Soviet museums were repainted.  Authenthicity of colours wasn't important for restorers.

Speaking of OKB Yakovlev's museum, it doesn't exist any more!  Yak-9 from your photo was fortunately saved by Zadorozhni Museum and it's displayed there now.  We can see how much they cared for old planes from "HSU Yeryomin's Yak-3 case" -  this Yak-3 was the most valuable exhibit in the collection and it was sold to Americans in early 1990es.

Of course, Yak-9 from your picture was repainted yet again while in the new museum:

(http://www.tmuseum.ru/media/exhibits/preview/588_390/img_4100.jpg)

(http://pics.livejournal.com/deyneka_oleg/pic/0006q3g8)

(http://pics.livejournal.com/deyneka_oleg/pic/0006rakb)

Are those authentic colours?????


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Massimo Tessitori on June 04, 2011, 12:47:07 PM
Hi Konstantin,
green over grey? What a shame!
It could be useful to find the earlier known photo of this plane to see if it looks changed respect to the image of the dismanted plane. Who has any information on that Kleshchev?
Regards
Massimo


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: KL on June 04, 2011, 05:39:39 PM
Who has any information on that Kleshchev?

HSU Ivan Ivanovich Kleshchov (Клещёв).  Acoording to M. Bikov 16 confirmed individual victories and 15 group victories.  Killed in landing accident on 31 December 1942.

http://allaces.ru/p/people.php?id=13284
http://www.allaces.ru/p/peoplecls.php?id=13284

(http://allaces.ru/sssr/foto2/kleshchov.jpg)

(http://allaces.ru/sssr/foto2/kleshchov01.jpg)

http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%9A%D0%BB%D0%B5%D1%89%D1%91%D0%B2,_%D0%98%D0%B2%D0%B0%D0%BD_%D0%98%D0%B2%D0%B0%D0%BD%D0%BE%D0%B2%D0%B8%D1%87

(http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/ru/e/e9/Kleshev_II.jpg)

Also at: http://airaces.narod.ru/all/kleshev1.htm

(http://airaces.narod.ru/all/kleshev9.jpg)

(http://airaces.narod.ru/all/kleshjak.jpg)

Last photo was taken in old OKB Yakovlev Museum



Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: KL on June 04, 2011, 06:13:22 PM
Yak-7 HSU Kleshchova:

(http://forums.airforce.ru/attachment.php?attachmentid=12561&d=1215889742)

(http://img134.imageshack.us/img134/2844/yak7434kk4.jpg)

Summer 1942 and standard green-black camouflage.

Cheers,
KL


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Massimo Tessitori on June 05, 2011, 06:58:44 AM
Hi Konstantin,
thank you for posting this research, I had researched something too and I think that, being dead in a crash, it's doubtful that his plane has survived.
However the marks of his  black-green Yak-7 have resemblance with those of this later one.
(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/colors/1943-45-fighters/yak7b8b.jpg)
Maybe this was his last plane... but I see much less victory marks.
AR will be on holidays for a pair of weeks, I have to wait to ask further explanations.
Regards
Massimo


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: KL on June 06, 2011, 09:21:17 PM
(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/colors/1943-45-fighters/yak7b8b.jpg)
Maybe this was his last plane... but I see much less victory marks.

Hi Massimo,

You are in Pilawskii?s territory!
Yak-7B from your photo is AII Green-Dark Green:

(http://i292.photobucket.com/albums/mm13/klesnikov/Posted%20in%20forums/Yak-7BTikhonov42IAP.jpg)


There are also different interpretations:

(http://www.airaces.narod.ru/all/yak7_42p.jpg)

from:  http://www.airaces.narod.ru/all4/german.htm

similarly depicted is S. Mikoyan?s Yak-9:

(http://militera.lib.ru/memo/russian/drabkin_ay3/72.jpg)

(http://militera.lib.ru/memo/russian/mikoyan_sa/14.jpg)

Another S. Mikoyan?s Yak; "White 27" (12 GvIAP):

(http://militera.lib.ru/memo/russian/mikoyan_sa/15.jpg)

(http://crimso.msk.ru/Images6/AM/AM02-3/44-3.jpg)

Cheers,
KL


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Massimo Tessitori on June 07, 2011, 06:59:35 AM
Hi Konstantin,
thank you for these images, those of Za borodo were new for me.
The photo of the line of Yaks behind the MiG-3 can give some indication: the MiG I-230 are thought to be grey-grey from other photos, they often are interpreted as green-light grey on old works.
But the most promising possibility is to find a better photo of the line of Yak-7 behind the n.27; they have to be green/black and would allow a comparison.
Regards
Massimo


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: John Thompson on June 07, 2011, 03:15:27 PM
But the most promising possibility is to find a better photo of the line of Yak-7 behind the n.27; they have to be green/black and would allow a comparison.
Regards
Massimo

That's easy - it's one of these:

(http://s4.postimage.org/1aaapthus/7_4.jpg) (http://postimage.org/image/1aaapthus/)

...although there's no way of knowing if it might have been repainted or not; the image Konstantin posted doesn't have very good resolution (I think I've seen it published somewhere where it's a bit clearer) but the Komsomol inscription is still faintly visible. I know I've seen some discussion of this photo elsewhere; Scalemodels.ru, probably.

John


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: KL on June 07, 2011, 06:40:20 PM
thank you for these images, those of Za borodo were new for me.

Mikoyan's Yak-9 carried inscription "Za Volodyu" ("For Volodya").  It referred to his brother Vladimir Mikoyan who was killed in action in Sept 1942.

(http://i292.photobucket.com/albums/mm13/klesnikov/Posted%20in%20forums/Yak-9ZaVolodyu_S_Mikoyan.jpg)

(http://militera.lib.ru/memo/russian/mikoyan_sa/14.jpg)

(http://airfield.narod.ru/yak/yak-9/color/photo_yak-9_14-2.jpg)

(http://airfield.narod.ru/yak/yak-9/color/pic_yak-9_14.jpg)

All photos were taken in March 1943 when Mikoyan was with 32th GvIAP.  The plane was most likely camouflaged in black-green scheme.

Cheers,
KL


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: learstang on June 07, 2011, 07:52:26 PM
Interesting pictures, Konstantin!  I notice that even though the photographs are from 1943, the Yak still has the prewar type red stars with the thin black outline.  Do you know how late these were used - did any aeroplanes use them until the end of the war (in other words is there any photographic evidence for this)?

Regards,

Jason


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Massimo Tessitori on June 07, 2011, 07:58:22 PM
Hi John,  Konstantin, Jason
Quote
That's easy - it's one of these:



...although there's no way of knowing if it might have been repainted or not; the image Konstantin posted doesn't have very good resolution (I think I've seen it published somewhere where it's a bit clearer) but the Komsomol inscription is still faintly visible. I know I've seen some discussion of this photo elsewhere; Scalemodels.ru, probably.
Good image John, althogh it doesn't allow a direct comparison with n.287; here the black is black, no doubt, but the green... again this high contrasting camouflage typical of so many Yaks...

Quote
Mikoyan's Yak-9 carried inscription "Za Volodyu" ("For Volodya").  It referred to his brother Vladimir Mikoyan who was killed in action in Sept 1942.

All photos were taken in March 1943 when Mikoyan was with 32th GvIAP.  The plane was most likely camouflaged in black-green scheme.
Thanks, really good images. Of course I have my doubts on black and green.

Quote
Interesting pictures, Konstantin!  I notice that even though the photographs are from 1943, the Yak still has the prewar type red stars with the thin black outline.  Do you know how late these were used - did any aeroplanes use them until the end of the war (in other words is there any photographic evidence for this)?
I would say, the summer of 1943. The change is more or less contemporary to the 1943 nkap scheme.

Regards
Massimo




Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: KL on June 07, 2011, 08:25:30 PM
Do you know how late these were used - did any aeroplanes use them until the end of the war (in other words is there any photographic evidence for this)?

Jason,
Red stars with wider white and thin red outline were introduced on Sept 03, 1943 by directive called "About the improvment of the visibility of the VVS KA markings".


... but the green... again this high contrasting camouflage typical of so many Yaks...

Massimo,
you missed one of my previous posts:


Two reasons why green AMT-4 looks dark gray on some b/w photos and light gray on others:

1.   Photos were taken with different types of film (different spectral sensitivity) combined with different optical filters
2.   AMT-4 had some special spectral properties ? it was non-decodable (nedeshifruemya)


LaGGs camouflaged in black-green scheme also show wide range of grays for AMT-4 painted areas:
 
(http://www.lietadla.com/lietadla/ruske/lagg-3/lagg-3-10.jpg)

(http://ww2warbirds.net/ww2pics/ww2lagglagg3-1.jpg)

Two photos above were taken with different types of film - red star is dark on the upper photo and almost white on the lower photo.



Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: learstang on June 07, 2011, 08:51:42 PM
Thank you for the information about the stars, Massimo and Konstantin!  So the "Victory" stars were officially introduced at about the same time as the three-colour scheme.

Regards,

Jason


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: John Thompson on June 07, 2011, 08:56:25 PM
Interesting pictures, Konstantin!  I notice that even though the photographs are from 1943, the Yak still has the prewar type red stars with the thin black outline.  Do you know how late these were used - did any aeroplanes use them until the end of the war (in other words is there any photographic evidence for this)?

Regards,

Jason

More on this topic:
http://s362974870.onlinehome.us/forums/air/index.php?showtopic=201636

John


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Massimo Tessitori on June 07, 2011, 10:57:20 PM
Hi Konstantin,
I read your post, but I continue to see that nearly all photos of Yaks shows high contrast, and photos of other planes not. I don't think that they use always the same film for yaks and few other planes only.
To find some new indication, we have to look for photos where Yaks and other types of planes are shown side by side.
Regards
Massimo


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: KL on June 08, 2011, 12:21:20 AM
I read your post, but I continue to see that nearly all photos of Yaks shows high contrast, and photos of other planes not.

You may say this way:  low contrast is visible on some Yaks and on many planes of other types.  I don't see anything strange there. ;)

I think that's result of different film types, different lighting, etc...  8)
You are suspecting that Yaks were painted with some different type of green paint...  :-X

Different approach....  ::)

High contrast examples from your own research (supposedly found only on Yaks):

(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/colors/1941-43/4photos.jpg)

(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/colors/1941-43/IL-2-2-SeatersinBlack-GreenFactoryFinish.jpg)

(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/colors/1941-43/su2-mg.jpg)

(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/colors/1941-43/u2s.jpg)

(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/colors/1941-43/li2b.jpg)

Cheers,
KL


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Massimo Tessitori on June 08, 2011, 07:28:09 AM
Hi Konstantin,
I know that high contrast appears also on photos of other types, but on Yaks it is so regular to cause the suspect that there has to be some non-casual reason.
Regards
Massimo


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Massimo Tessitori on June 16, 2011, 07:58:25 AM
Hi Konstantin,
here are two photos from the booklet of Orlov:
(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/colors/1943-45-fighters/yak9parm1.jpg)
(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/colors/1943-45-fighters/yak9parm2.jpg)
As you read in the text of the book, they always restored the pre-existing camouflages with AMT colors They have just repainted a plane. So, the darker color is fresh, can't be faded black. Is it fresh black, in your opinion? I would say not. And it appears exactly identical to that of the supposed prototype of grey-grey planes in 1943, and to that of Yak-7b in late 1942. None of the known photos shows the characteristic look of black-green planes, although having been shot with different films in different occasions. This is evidence for me.
To say nothing about the fact that painting the sides light blue and the part under the tail with a darker color makes sense only for a camouflage destined to mask the plane on the horizon, not certainly on the ground.
 
Regards
Massimo


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Walker on June 16, 2011, 10:12:10 AM
Hi all,
looking at photos of Yaks, I am strongly suspecting that something should be rewritten.
Probably the first application of AMT-11 and 12 on many Yakovlev planes, in 1943, was made according to a different scheme that we can describe as 'serpentine'.
(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/colors/1943-45-fighters/yak9-niivvs.jpg)
Image from SAFFC by EP It has often interpreted as a tricky black-green or tractor green-dark green scheme, but the photo here allows the comparison with the colors of the MiG-3, Il-2 and Pe-2, and it's clear that it can't absolutely be the same. So, it's likely that this was a first application of AMT-11/12.
Note the high contour of the AMT-7 light blue demarcation line on the fuselage sides, that encourages the interpretation as a blue-gray plane, and the early style marks.
Note the wing of a La-5, believed to be white or light grey overall.

Massimo

I have a picture on the other side. Indeed color Yak-9 look like 11/12. But I think that this is non-standard experimental painting, which is just at that time was tested. Two-color on the Yak-9 and three-color on the Yak-1. As a result, two-color scheme was approved by the camouflage, but with modified forms of spots. La-5F really looks like a very light gray.
http://propjet.ucoz.ru/photo/1-0-4-3

Here is a picture of that Yak-9 during testing of the new scheme:
http://propjet.ucoz.ru/photo/1-0-5-3

As you can see it the same plane. A color scheme, the same two-color camouflage first experimental adopted later in modified forms spots.


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Massimo Tessitori on June 16, 2011, 12:34:47 PM
Hi Walker,
thank you for the links, but for some reason I can't see the photos. Has one to subscribe that forum?
This plane is really grey/grey, by sure. As you read, my idea is that colors were utilized even before because nearly all of the Yaks that resemble this plane as shape of camouflage resemble to it for colors too.
Besides, a wide light blue blotch on the fuselage sides in a position well visible from above, and a dark band passing under the tail where it is visible only from below, suggest an air-to-air masking.
I would like to know if there exist images of such planes strongly suggesting usual black/green colors on this shape of camo.
Maybe have you the possibilty to ask to Mr. Orlov to discuss this topic, please?
Regards
Massimo


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Walker on June 16, 2011, 05:13:26 PM
As I wrote above, this picture of Yak-9 was held in the Institute of Air Force tests new camouflage scheme with the Yak-1. Yak-9 was painted in two colors top blue-gray AMT-11 and dark-gray AMT-12. Two Yaka were painted: the first in two standard colors: green and black. The second of three: green, black and light brown. According to the results of tests was selected two-tone camouflage scheme AMT-11/AMT-12 but with modified forms of spots. Accordingly, in a series of aircraft were painted in this scheme but also to other fields of camouflage. All other photos are listed in this thread with other aircraft is likely to relate to the aircraft passed the PARM s Field aviation maintenance workshops, where planes were painted in a completely non-standard camouflage with a completely non-traditional spots. As proof of this is the set of photos.

Unfortunately I can not attach a photo. On it the same Yak-9 during testing camouflage coloring.


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: KL on June 16, 2011, 09:35:41 PM
I have a picture on the other side. Indeed color Yak-9 look like 11/12. But I think that this is non-standard experimental painting, which is just at that time was tested. Two-color on the Yak-9 and three-color on the Yak-1. As a result, two-color scheme was approved by the camouflage, but with modified forms of spots. La-5F really looks like a very light gray.
http://propjet.ucoz.ru/photo/1-0-4-3

Hi Walker,  :)

thanks for the interesting photo!  I had to register to your page to view it.  :D

Do you have any additional information about these photos, like the date when the photo was taken?
That must be He-100 in front of La-5?

Cheers,
KL


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Massimo Tessitori on June 17, 2011, 09:18:07 AM
Quote
All other photos are listed in this thread with other aircraft is likely to relate to the aircraft passed the PARM s Field aviation maintenance workshops, where planes were painted in a completely non-standard camouflage with a completely non-traditional spots. As proof of this is the set of photos.
Hi Walker,
I think that it's possible that some planes were repainted with grey over green black after summer 1943, but it's not likely for me, because the photos of planes dated to 1942 have the same look of those taken in 1943 and surely grey/grey. It is possible that one photo was of a repainted plane, another photo is tricky for exposure reasons etc, but here is a fairly good number of photos all pointing in the same direction.
I think that, if a plane is repainted after August 1943, PARM should follow the new scheme, not the old one. However, the interview  says that they usually simply restored previous painting.
Now there is another possibility: I'm sure that there are other photos of planes with this painting scheme, that was not rare and easily recognizable. We can collect all the existing ones to see if we find an adequate number, or any, strongly suggesting that a green/black variant of this painting did exist; there is not any difficulty to find many photo confirming green-black use for other patterns, why should be such difficulty for this one only?
Regards
Massimo


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Walker on June 17, 2011, 11:13:08 AM
After the adoption of the scheme AMT-11/12, the camouflage was applied to the aircraft factories for new aircraft. In the "PARM" could also be repainted aircraft after repairs in these colors. What made it the most unusual and unconventional color.
In addition, some plant were painted its planes with deviations from the standard color scheme. For example plant number 21.
Order number 389S/0133 NCAP and VVS RKKA July 3, 1943, the beginning of the new aircraft painting aircraft factory, scheduled from July 15, 1943. Attack aircraft and bombers from August 1.
Before 15 July were ordered released on the new aircraft until the new paint, replaced by black to dark gray. A gray-blue color by mixing blue and AMT-7 black AMT-6 colors. Prepared by the time the aircraft in black-and-green color is not repainted. Instructed to send in the part of the same number of aircraft in both stains. Repaint fought at the time of the shelves, too, not repainted aircraft. Only those that were repaired in the "Parma".
The process of transition from black-green to gray-gray gradually, as the failure of the old aircraft and replaced with new in a new color.


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Walker on June 17, 2011, 11:15:26 AM
Hi Walker,  :)

thanks for the interesting photo!  I had to register to your page to view it.  :D

Do you have any additional information about these photos, like the date when the photo was taken?
That must be He-100 in front of La-5?

Cheers,
KL

Yes it is He-100 bought before the war, and passing the test in NII VVS.


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Massimo Tessitori on June 17, 2011, 01:39:34 PM
Hi Walker,
thank you, this is a translation from Orlov. This will be useful to many.
I exposed my idea after having read the automatic translation of the text.  Now, I am suspecting that there is something to add, and relative to the Yaks made in that factory only, not to planes in general.
Regards
Massimo


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: KL on June 17, 2011, 07:24:06 PM
looking at photos of Yaks, I am strongly suspecting that something should be rewritten.

Obviously you need a better translation of V&O texts - some answers on your questions are there.

But, why would anybody waste time and effort translating it if you believe that history based on documents can be rewritten because there is a "photographic evidence" that may, or may not, show something else? ???

Regards,
KL


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: learstang on June 17, 2011, 07:49:10 PM
looking at photos of Yaks, I am strongly suspecting that something should be rewritten.

Obviously you need a better translation of V&O texts - some answers on your questions are there.

But, why would anybody waste time and effort translating it if you believe that history based on documents can be rewritten because there is a "photographic evidence" that may, or may not, show something else? ???

Regards,
KL

Actually, Konstantin, I believe we were waiting on you to finish a translation of V&O's work.

Regards,

Jason


Title: Re: early grey/grey serpentine camouflage on Yaks
Post by: Massimo Tessitori on October 03, 2013, 07:10:04 PM
Hi,
I've found some interesting images at
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tZDMfJdkESI (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tZDMfJdkESI)
at 4:13
(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/yak179/Yak-9/greygreyserpentine.jpg)
The planes are clearly under the same light conditions, but the difference of shades between them is evident.
Some more images from the movie, cutting and enlarging the details of the planes without making any change to the shade:
(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/yak179/Yak-9/greygreyserpentineclose.jpg)
The dark plane has clearly a black-gren camouflage, while the lighter one is clearly related to these ones:
(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/yak179/Yak-9/yak9-niivvs-r.jpg)
that is known as a grey-grey plane of spring 1943 (the prototype of grey-grey planes, as widely thought till now)
(http://mig3.sovietwarplanes.com/yak179/Yak-7/yak7b8b.jpg)
a Yak-7 late type of late 1942
and other photos of similar planes built in z.115 in late 1942 and the first half of 1943.
Regards
Massimo